cstravato's Pre-k World

The life of a Teacher / Student / Mother

An Unexpected Experience with Bias In My Classroom

4 Comments

In an effort to set up a classroom environment of diversity, I tried to be mindful of materials I included in each center. While setting up the home dramatic play center, I tried to be aware of including foods from various cultures, dolls of varying of races, family book depicting a variety of cultures and races, and so on. I thought I had done a good job of reducing any chance a student would feel invisible or oppressed. For the most part, I think I accomplished my goal.

However, one day I observed a play scene with a few children that concerned me. There are four dolls and four girls in the center at the time of the observation. Three of the girls had a baby doll and one was trying to pull a doll from another child. I asked the girls why they were upset, there was another baby doll in the crib. The two girls pulling on the one doll said they did not like that doll. The doll left in the crib was of Asian race, they had the Caucasian doll, the Hispanic doll, and the black doll. I asked the other two girls if they would trade and they said they did not want to play with that doll either. I was surprised at the response I received from the girls. This caused me to stop and reflect on what I was observing and hearing. I felt I had failed in my effort to model and create an environment of equity for all.

Our class was made up of primarily Caucasian students, one child who’s family is from Guyana, and one child who’s family is from Mexico, not great diversity within our population. Regardless of the limited diversity within the classroom, I try to teach and set up a classroom that supports diversity. This observation could be seen as a racial micro-aggression, in the sense the children did not what to play with that doll because of the race it represented. It could also be seen as children playing out what they are familiar with, the dolls that were being used did represent the diversity of the classroom at the time. It could also simply be that doll was not designed in a way that appealed as well to the children as the other dolls.

Regardless of what the original cause of this action was, I knew as a major role model in the classroom I needed to take action to support the positive growth and development of my students. So I first helped the two girls fighting over the one doll realize they could share the responsibly of taking care of the baby. They were able to work out which childcare roles each of them would take on. I choose to pretend the last baby in the crib was crying and need someone to take care of her. So I picked up the baby changed her diaper, dressed her, feed her, and talked to her. The girls were happy I joined their play and they helped me get things I needed to take care of the baby. Soon there was an incident in an other center that required my attention, so I asked the girl who was not holding a baby at that time to help me by watching over my baby while I was gone. She was happy to take over and help. I eventually made my way back and asked if she needed me to take the baby back. She said it was her baby now and she was making dinner for her. This made me feel like I had had a positive influence and our classroom was back on track being respectful and inclusive of all.

I could have chosen to ignore what I observed or dismissed it as nothing. However, my goal is to instill a sense of shared interconnectedness for all my students and all people they will meet throughout their lives. “Society needs to realize the suppression and oppression of one group oppresses me and my group as well (Laureate, 2011).” It is just as important for me to be positive role model for the diversity within my classroom as well as it is for the diversity outside my classroom.

 

Reference

Laureate Education (Producer). (2011). Microaggressions in everyday life [Video file]

Sue, D. W. (2010). Microaggressions in everyday life: Race, gender, and sexual orientation. New York, NY: Wiley

 

 

 

Advertisements

Author: cstravato

I am a wife of 14 years and have two boys, one is 10 and an the other is 8. They are busy and keep us hopping. I have been a pre-school teacher for 9 years with a break in the middle to teach kindergarten in FL for three years, and I had the luxury of staying home with my two boys for a few years. I enjoy teaching pre-school age children it gives me great pride to help set a generation up to succeed in their school careers and life. I am currently going back to school to complete my masters degree in early childhood education at Walden University.

4 thoughts on “An Unexpected Experience with Bias In My Classroom

  1. Thank you for sharing your experience Christina. It’s wonderful how you are making a conscious effort to include different ethnic backgrounds into your classroom It’s one thing to have the knowledge, but it’s a whole other skill set to be able to put it into practice. It’s unfortunate that the incident happened, but what a wonderful teaching opportunity it created. You set the example and your students followed, it’s as simple as that.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Oh jeez…thanks for that morning set of tears!!! 🙂 This was a wonderful story – and I can’t help but be filled with such excitement and joy at the way you handled this situation. You could have easily blamed or reprimanded the girls for their exclusionary play, but instead, you became the detective and deduced what they needed was good old fashioned modeling. Building a classroom climate of inclusion and pro-diversity is only half the battle; children will spend time withing their own family structures and those environments may look and feel anything like the ones we create. I would think this type of example would slowing germinate within the children and perhaps they could model this positively beautiful behavior at home – because, in the end, that’s where it all starts.

    Kudos and high fives all around! Thanks for the positive start to my day!

    Heidi

    Like

  3. It always amazes me how those babies become the center of bias feelings whether totally understood or not. I have seen this within my classroom as well and it always takes an adult to help those children see all the babies are lovable and need to be loved. Our job is filled with so many teachable moments and I love that we get to be such positive role models within the lives of each child we serve on a daily basis. Those children are watching us and following our examples. We are a starting point to a greater future for all!! Thanks for sharing and being an inspiration.
    Heidi

    Like

  4. Great job intervening and being an example to the other girls. I am surprised they left the asian baby in the crib. It reveals a new kind of interaction the children have not encountered. I do like how you asked on of the little girls to take care of your baby and she gladly did. I wonder what went through her mind afterwards. As hard as we try to create a diverse environment, there will be some aspects we will inadvertently miss because we think of it as normal. Most importantly, you didn’t ignore the situation.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s